South Dakota Mulls New Definition of Animal Torture
Jodie Hickman, Executive Director, SDCA
South Dakota Cattlemen’s Legislative Blog
SDCA joined many other livestock groups in opposing HB 1146 which proposed to implement a new definition for animal torture and make animal torture a Class 6 felony. To be clear – SDCA doesn’t condone animal torture. However, we opposed HB 1146 primarily due to concerns about how normal livestock production practices, such as castration and de-horning, might be interpreted under the proposed definition of torture. We believe the state’s existing statutes are appropriate to address the minimal problems with animal abuse in SD and, fortunately, the House Judiciary Committee agreed when they sent HB 1146 to the 41st day on a vote of 12-0 (with one member absent). Livestock producers had additional concerns with HB 1146 because its language was similar to language proposed last summer by the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) – the same group responsible for banning horse slaughter in the United States. HSUS has publicly stated their goal is to end animal agriculture in the U.S. and SDCA resisted the passage of HB 1146 in hopes it would discourage this activist group from trying to establish state laws that would be detrimental to the livestock industry.
